forums.marpirc.net

You have two choices:
<p>

a. Pick the top ten yourselves via the normal voting method from the top 30.

<p>

b. Pick ten games out of random from the top 30.(I'll do that... I know enough QBasic to do so... it ain't that hard)

<p>

I need to know ASAP please. Thanks

--
goldengameboy@yahoo.com

People have voted on our new IRC channel - they have voted for the
following:
<p>

Randomize - gameboy9, zwaxy, aquatarkus, brian mclean

<p>

vote - crash

<p>

vote stands at 4 - 1.

--
goldengameboy@yahoo.com

I'll vote random.

--
info@kaupp.cx

The random is best when picked from all games, but i like keeping as
much of the predefined rules (non changing ones) as possible, so i
have to vote to vote.

--
churritz@cts.com

random random random

--
qan@home.com

I think a random choice for the 10 games since the beginning is too
much risky....the could have a tournament with 10 "Us vs Them", and
it will be 2 months of deadly bore !!!

<p>

So, let's take votes first, maybe allowing just 1 (max 2) games per
category (sport, vector, shooter, fighting, etc...), then we should
pick 10 randomly out of the first 30.

<p>

This should ensure high quality games in the Tourny, and discourage
gang voting.

<p>

Cicca

--
cicca@writeme.com

let's randomize it - i think it's too stupid to vote and vote and
vote ... and you won't stop the party-voters otherwise!
It's just 4 fun folks !!!

--
christian@rduch.de

The reason I posted the original group voting technique, was to show
that a few players could manipulate the tournament voting.

<p>

If only the top 30 games are in the random pool, a few players still
have a chance to manipulate the random pool.

<p>

There are quite a few games below the 30 mark that would be great for
a tournament. There are also quite a few in the top 30 that in my
opiniun would not be good in a tournament.

<p>

Why not draw the random games from all the games submitted, removing
any obvious games that should not not be in a tournament.

--
info@kaupp.cx

I vote for random in top 30. That will make it fair.
<p>

regards,
Stig Remnes

--
sremnes@samsen.com

Here's an idea I got - everyone would select numbers from 1 to 30 -
via the 10 points for "favorite", 1 point for the "10th favorite"

<p>

Those numbers I would compare with a randomly selected list, which
will be told to a couple unbiased witnesses. Top ten gets those games
put into the tournament. That way... it'll be completely random.
Heck... you get to vote as well... in one sense.

<p>

What do you think?

--
goldengameboy@yahoo.com

BTW... on a 10 - 2 vote(I think), we WILL be randomizing... now we
have to figure out how to do it...

--
goldengameboy@yahoo.com